St. Albans Messenger logo Essex Reporter logo Milton Independent logo Colchester Sun logo

‘We are purposeful with what we do’

Franklin County schools take a closer look at technology in the classroom

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — When Franklin West Supervisory Union Superintendent John Tague walks school hallways, he sees students working in small groups, rotating between work on a computer, on paper, with models and directly with teachers.

After years of embracing technology with open arms, schools across the country have shifted to look a little more closely at what, when and how to use the tech with their students. 

Schools leaned heavily on content found on the computer during the COVID-19 pandemic, but have since turned around to be more focused and intentional with their use of personal devices. 

Computer leases are up for renewal at FWSU’s three schools and at other districts around Vermont, prompting lively discussion among school boards.  

There's both a push and a pull from school board members, administrators and the general public over technology’s place in the classroom. 

Missisquoi Valley School District Superintendent Julie Regimbal said she expects state lawmakers to weigh in more heavily in the coming years, especially as new advances like artificial intelligence become deeper entwined with the Big Tech suppliers who’ve been leasing personal devices for student use. 

In the rough decade since personal devices such as Google Chromebooks and Apple iPads entered into daily student life, school districts have been tracking, tweaking and trying to find the balance between traditional paper learning and use of tech. 

“We just always are paying attention,” Regimbal said. “It needs to be a balance, and the balance needs to be toward human interaction more than technology. One has to be in service of the other.”

Students use the driving simulator in Enosburg Falls High School before they get behind the wheel of a real vehicle. FNESU technology integrationist Robert Hickey said he's heard from driving instructors students feel more comfortable driving having been through the simulator first.
Students use the driving simulator in Enosburg Falls High School before they get behind the wheel of a real vehicle. FNESU technology integrationist Robert Hickey said he's heard from driving instructors students feel more comfortable driving having been through the simulator first.
Aidan Schonbrun

Technology’s assistance 

Across the state, one-to-one computing is where the most technology is directly in the hands of students. According to the Agency of Education's 2024 annual tech survey, the most recent publicly-available data, that means some 87,000 devices are available for student use across Vermont. 

One-to-one programming is a system where students have a computer or device dedicated to them over the course of a school year or multiple years. 

When personal devices were first marketed to districts, schools saw the influx of technology as positive and took to them with ferocity, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, creating what Robert Hickey the technology and innovation coordinator for the Franklin Northeast Supervisory Union called a sort of “Wild West.” Some schools had already integrated technology into curriculums, while others had not, and some teachers lacked the necessary training. 

Schools have since taken a step back, having seen how student behavior has changed in the years since. 

Administrators understand technology has a place in the classroom, but in order for a new piece to come into the curriculum, teachers, staff and tech integrationists have to ask the same question: is there a reason for this or does it simply replace a pen and paper? 

“We’re a low-spending district. We have to be careful,” Regimbal said. “We don’t just say, ‘Let's go do this thing, this looks fun.’ We look at use. We look at how well it is moving students toward what we want them to learn, and we look at that return on investment.”

“Frankly, we’re looking at less screen time, not more screen time,” she continued. “More books in kids' hands, as a rule, without taking their Chromebooks away.”

That disciplined approach is how districts in Franklin County are moving forward with their use of technology. 

FWSU, which has had one-to-one devices for over a decade, utilizes tech in the classroom to supplement, not teach a course. The focus lies in using a device to enhance a student’s understanding, Tague said. 

“We try to use them intentionally, try to use them in ways that are reinforcing, that are actively engaging and support the curriculums,” he said. “Not as curriculum, not as instruction, but ways to reinforce. In the younger grades especially, we want them to reinforce concepts, provide practice in a different format and certainly not using them for direct instruction.” 

In order to do so, tech integrationists like Hickey are looking at the S.A.M.R. model of substitution, augmentation, modification and redefinition to craft a structured way of incorporating new technology effectively into lesson plans and to boost student engagement. 

“It’s a simple way to look at a technology tool,” he said. “Be like, ‘Does this just replace paper and pencil? Is that all that’s doing, or does it offer tangible benefits, or would that learning experience have been impossible without the use of technology?’”

And, for schools looking at their next leasing contract, Tague said it means spending the year looking at what device school staff and administrators want students to be able to use, what a new device can provide, what safeguards are in place and the cost. 

Rather than abiding by the precedent of, “everybody has a Chromebook and so it should be used,” Hickey said his job is to get teachers to assess if it's the proper tool for the job, or if there's something they can do better to enhance the learning experience. 

‘Creators not users’

Personal computing devices are only one part of the technology used in schools. Active technology moves kids away from sitting and staring at screens, articles or videos and instead gets them interacting with the lesson. 

Active use involves more critical thinking — activities like coding, media production, lesson interaction, design and peer collaboration — while passive use is menial work like filling out digital worksheets, or consuming digital content without participation. 

Whether that’s building a working cell in virtual reality, sitting down in a driving simulator before getting behind the wheel of a real car or engineering using 3D printers, active technologies are used to deepen student knowledge in different ways. 

“We’re actually shifting from screen time to how we get students to engage,” Hickey said. “Classes are going more screen-free. We want creators not users.” 

In FNESU, the virtual reality program called Prisms is a hit for educators. 

The math and science program has seen 342 students use at least one module this school year. After the 15-20 minute module wraps up, teachers assign a “check for understanding” quiz. The first three questions are directly around the module and student perception. Of the students who have answered those questions, 87% have credited the program as “essential” for their understanding, he said. 

Modules built inside the VR headset focus on certain “pain points” with more abstract elements students may struggle to understand. The VR gives a spatial sense, where the students can physically interact with the math and science concepts. 

“When we’ve got 87% of our kids saying, ‘Hey I found a lot of value in that; it helped my understanding,’ that means it’s an avenue we’ve got to continue exploring,” Hickey said. “That doesn’t necessarily mean increasing the amount of modules we’re doing, but rather expanding to how many students have access to it, and making sure we’re choosing the right audiences for it.” 

An interactive topographic map created by Hickey allows students to use technology to interact with maps and get a real sense of how certain conditions affect the landscape.
An interactive topographic map created by Hickey allows students to use technology to interact with maps and get a real sense of how certain conditions affect the landscape.
Aidan Schonbrun
Away from screens, Hickey also spent his time this semester creating a cheap and digitally-interactive topographic map system. The map shows the heights, depths and measurements of mounds created in the sand, and updates in real time. 

Teachers can use it to get students to understand topographical maps, see how fire spreads or how flooding and pollution can move along the Missisquoi River, as an example, all while allowing students to interact with the map.

And, unlike a picture on their computer, it pushes students to ask more questions and experiment to find the answer.

“It’s more than just showing them pictures, telling them or showing them videos,” Hickey said. “It's tactile feedback, they can build things up with it, they can play with it, but then it also gives them that physical sense for something they can recall.”

“There’s lots of different technology which enhances student in-depth learning,” he continued.

For both Regimbal and Tague, technology of all shapes and sizes has a place in the classroom if it deepens learning in an engaging way. 

Or put simply; “We never want to see it used like babysitting,” Regimbal said. 

Some pushback 

MVSD tracks device time in the district. In Kindergarten, the most any student will get is 11 minutes on a device in a single day, while tenth-graders at the peak of screen time see just about two hours. 

The one thing Regimabal said she doesn’t see is kids staring at their screens all day.

Not everyone, however, sees the influx of technology and student devices in a positive light. 

Nearly two-thirds of the districts in the Consortium for School Networking, a nationwide advocacy group promoting the integration of technology in the K-12 space, reported communities in their network express moderate to high level concern about the tech used for teaching and learning, according to its 2026 U.S. State of EdTech report. 

Vermont’s legislature has already banned phones in schools and has bounced around ideas to reign-in district tech, but it’s the Los Angeles Unified School District in California which took the biggest step away from technology this year by becoming the first major school district to stop giving devices to its youngest students. 

Essentially, the resolution passed by the Los Angeles school board requires the district to eliminate devices until second grade, set daily and weekly screen limits for all higher grades, block YouTube on school devices and ban devices at lunch and recess in elementary and middle school. 

The concerns boiled down to growing calls for reform around tech, screen time and overreliance on technology. 

Those concerns are the same ones some local board members, like Jean-Charles Thouin of Georgia, have been lobbying superintendents with. 

Speaking on his own behalf and not for the board, Thouin told the Messenger he sees five different types of educational technology: learning tools, learning aid, communication, assignment tools, and creations, but they all come with steep prices on the backs of taxpayers. 

In Georgia, the four-year Apple technology contract costs $157,323, while technology in general made up 2.9% of the approved fiscal year 2027 budget. 

“I think some specific technology can be beneficial in schools, but I think it’s wrong to assume more technology is always better for the kids,” Thouin said. “I think society really should wonder if Big Tech has the school's interest or their own financial gain at heart.” 

An overreliance on technology is dangerous, Thouin added, as it can hurt students’ attention spans and concentration, slow handwriting and fine motor skills and hinder social development if used for too long.

Tague and Regimbal, however, said they are preparing their upper elementary, middle and high school students for the current world and would be doing a disservice to their kids if their schools were devoid of all tech. 

“Any job people have, most people have some sort of technology they’re going to use,” Tague said. “It’s very rare that people are doing things pencil and paper. Whether you’re an architect, an engineer, an accountant, or a police officer, everyone is using devices, so we want our students to be comfortable with it.” 

Thouin counters that kids are already overly exposed to personal technology outside of school, so why should there be even more in the classroom? 

“I find it contradictory that Vermont has a law banning personal devices in class, but the school gives each student a personal device,” he said. “And even though there are restrictions on what the devices can and can’t do, students have always found a way around those restrictions.” 

It’s a fair question, Regimbal said, but kids spend a lot of time in the classroom interacting with other people, which is something they strive to keep intact. 

Schools are also able to monitor inappropriate behavior on a school-issued device and intervene, something they can’t do at home. 

In FNESU, Vermont’s phone ban got rid of the immediate distractions the devices caused, but educators said it’s not the screens themselves where the problem lies. 

To Hickey, it’s the quality of the content which matters more. The goal can’t be a hard limit of time, but it can be training and supporting teachers to be more intentional when they use Chromebooks and what they’re using them for. 

“I fully agree, students are spending too much time on screens in school, out of school, all of it,” he said. “But the problem is not the number of minutes. It’s the quality of what they’re doing.” 

“We need to shift our focus from what actually matches the learning goals we’re trying to achieve and how does technology as a tool help that?” Hickey continued. “If it doesn’t help our learning goals then, why are we using it?”

Franklin Northeast Supervisory Union technology and innovation coordinator, Robert Hickey, shows off 3D printers in Enosburg Falls Middle and High School. The printers are helping students unlock another creative side, he said.
Franklin Northeast Supervisory Union technology and innovation coordinator, Robert Hickey, shows off 3D printers in Enosburg Falls Middle and High School. The printers are helping students unlock another creative side, he said.
Aidan Schonbrun

‘Trying to fly a plane while building it’

Artificial intelligence technology promises to change the world —  albeit with no specifics — and educators have spent the last couple of years wrapping their brains around it. 

It’s a fact, educators have said: students are using artificial intelligence already and each school’s response to that information is a little bit different. 

All of the schools in the county, however, are clear to make sure students do not become overreliant and keep AI use outside of the younger kids’ classrooms. 

“My concerns; cognitive offloading,” Hickey said. “In terms of cheating, kids always cheat and always find ways to cheat, the problem with AI is it's not just cheating anymore. It's cheating and then it's doing the task for you.” 

Regardless, the AI systems are in place and administrators are working to find the correct balance as they have with personal devices. 

“It’s a good thing, and it can potentially be a bad thing,” Tague said. “I think we, again, owe students the opportunity to develop skills because AI is part of the world and so we want students to use it in ways that are helpful.”

For students in Franklin West, the expectation of making students who are digital citizens and digitally literate, requires kids to be able to discern when things are real versus artificially-created and when AI information is accurate or biased. 

To get them there, students need to be used to the system’s functionality, Tague said. 

Knowing how to ask good questions is a bonus in an AI-filled world. If students learn at a young age the difference between open and closed questions, Tague explained, they can ask for and find more accurate information from an AI database. 

By 7th and 8th grades, Tague said when students might be probing AI they will already have experience in good question asking and discerning real information. 

It’s a similar thought process for tech integrationists like Hickey, whose role this year has shifted a little to keep up with the changes in the AI landscape. 

“My primary focus has been to kind of pump the brakes on just a fast, dirty AI rollout,” Hickey said. “We don’t want that. It’s using it responsibly, not just handing the keys over to kids and being like ‘Have at it,’ but teaching our teachers first.” 

The supervisory union wants their students to have the know-how to safely interact with the tools without giving up sensitive information or critical skills. 

In the Missisquoi Valley School District, there’s a more hesitant approach to AI. 

It’s not that there are no positives, Regimbal said, as it can help synthesize vast amounts of information, help teachers quickly modify lessons for particular students and they want their kids to be prepared for the AI-world, but there’s also a belief the specific career students will go in, will teach industry-specific AI uses. 

Schools like MVU have adopted more strict guidelines than the recommended policy coming from the Agency of Education. MVU has no student-facing use of AI like chatbots before sixth-grade. 

But because the technology is new, it’s left schools in a precarious position. 

“It feels like you’re trying to fly a plane while building it a little bit,” Regimbal said. “We really want to focus on the skills needed before, but they really need to learn to evaluate the tools and what’s real and what’s not real.”

For tech-questioning school board members like Thouin, long-term pushes for AI adoption are particularly dangerous. 

Part of learning is overcoming adversity and managing to work past difficulties, but as students accept AI into their lives, Thouin said students are not practicing those skills. The bigger concern, however, comes from the way AI talks and lack of strong guardrails. 

“AI always sounds, reads, or appears like factual information with a very authoritative tone. This tricks our brain into assuming it is true, correct, complete and unbiased,” he said. “This is far from the truth and not having those critical thinking tendencies make it even easier to be influenced by the corporations running the AI models.” 

The insistent push from Big Tech to use AI and the easy access from school devices — specifically Chromebooks — also raises red flags. 

In August, the company switched on the Gemini chatbot for many K-12 students and earlier this month, Google announced classrooms would not be allowed access to the tech giant’s search engine unless the district also opted into using the AI platform. 

New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago public school districts, three of the largest in the country, have since said they are considering alternatives to Google’s platform.

The vast majority of schools in Vermont use Chromebooks and Google’s education apps are universally utilized in every district, according to the AOE’s tech report. 

The local response has varied. 

In Missisquoi, Regimbal said the district shut off the student’s ability to search in Chrome, because students may struggle to understand what is AI generated and what is not without previous experience. Unless things change, the district could be looking at a permanent switch to other search platforms and engines like Firefox or Duck Duck Go. 

“While in some ways [kids] are tech savvier about things, my worry is: Are they going to be able to evaluate and understand what is true and what is not? What is vulnerable information and what is not? What’s a good source and what’s a bad source?” Regimbal said. 

From Tague’s reading, because Google has built up so many AI features into Chrome, the search engine would be forced to go back to an outdated format, making it harder for Franklin West to prepare students for the AI-using world. 

And, unlike other AI giants like ChatGPT, the district’s Gemini account is safer, Tague said, because the data stays localized, rather than being used to build up the larger language model. 

In the northeast corner of Franklin County, discussions have been to wait and see if Google backs down before they make any moves because schools make up a large part of Google’s business. 

“If we were to push back significantly to a point where they felt some stress, our hope is they would backtrack on that,” Hickey said. 

Still, all three school administrators said the best thing they can do for students is stay up to date with the changes in technology, behaviors of tech companies, and have policies to keep their data, students and families safe. 

“The struggle is the technology changes so rapidly and schools really aren’t designed to adapt to changes as rapidly as the tech changes. We’re constantly, as we find new information, re-evaluating and making sure we’re providing great opportunities for our students, providing real world opportunities,” Tague said. “As we learn more, we adjust and we adapt to make sure we’re doing what’s best, but it changes at such an exponential rate it’s really hard to keep up with.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here