St. Albans Messenger logo Essex Reporter logo Milton Independent logo Colchester Sun logo

Loud noises, bad smells; City Council combats quality of life issues

Posted

ST. ALBANS — Loud noises and bad smells took up the majority of St. Albans City Council’s time this past Monday as they tackled quality of life issues in the downtown core.

The problems? Speeding, drivers revving engines and renewed concerns about a sulphurous smell allegedly emanating from Dairy Farmers of America’s milk treatment plant. 

Council heard from St. Albans Police Department’s Lt. Paul Talley about the noise to get an overview of traffic enforcement, and the city administration brought a renewed case to council for a repeat attempt to prove DFA hasn’t done enough to eliminate problematic odors.

“We continue to get complaints, four to five a week, that people can’t stand living next to the plant,” City Manager Dominic Cloud said.

Downtown noises

The first 45 minutes of the council's three-hour meeting this past Monday largely focused on traffic enforcement. Ward 2 Councilor Lindsay Hunn said quality of life issues had been a major focus of the council’s recent public safety committee meeting, and they asked SAPD to present more information about what can be done to meet the issue. 

St. Albans City Mayor Trudy Cioffi defined the problem as “loud vehicles, speeding vehicles — all the fun stuff that I think every community in Vermont is dealing with right now.”

“It’s a hot topic for all of us for a while,” she said, referring to fellow councilors.

Lt. Talley, who regularly teaches traffic enforcement at the Vermont Police Academy, took up the effort. On Monday, he explained how officers will use a combination of data tracking and local complaints to try to pinpoint trouble areas.

“We know some hotspots from daily activities,” Talley said. People will sometimes call when they see issues, and he said the police department can set up devices which will bring in further traffic data to know where and when speeding is at its worst.

SAPD has also increased its traffic enforcement operations since the weather has warmed. In the last 30 days, he said officers completed 51 direct patrols which led to 267 traffic stops. About one in ten ended up with a ticket.

But has speeding increased this year? Are people driving more erratically?

It’s hard to say. The data doesn’t really reflect as much, and year-over-year comparisons can be hard to make when the department is using its resources differently, Talley said.

Compared to last summer, for example, St. Albans Police Department has seen a significant reduction in the calls-for-service received, when a glut of car robberies had people worried and asking for expanded services. This summer though, traffic enforcement seems to be higher on people’s list of concerns.

Hunn followed up, asking if the people speeding are the same drivers with loud vehicles. Multiple people in the audience also asked about the noise disruptions, as they have tried to use various tactics and devices to try to cover-up the traffic and train noises just to get to sleep at night. 

Again, that’s hard to determine, Talley said. The City of St. Albans did pass a sound ordinance back in 2021 to try to tamp down on noise disruptions, but the enforcement of the law can be tricky. Someone with a loud idling motorcycle, for example, may be disruptive, but it likely doesn’t constitute criminal behavior. Instead, police are looking for people revving engines or going out of their way to make loud noises.

“It’s their performance,” Talley said. “it’s whether they’re purposely doing it to make their engine run. They rev it, keeping it in gear for high rpms to make it louder, but we have to be there to be able to hear it.”

Additionally, police still need to prove in court that a problem occurred. A complaint from a citizen doesn’t always convince a judge, so police usually need to be the ones who experience the issue to qualify as sure evidence. 

There is also technology which can find bad actors via tracking sounds of passing vehicles, Talley said, but it’s cost-prohibitive and hasn’t been used in Vermont.

If local residents want to see a change, however, SAPD encourages residents to speak up about problem areas. The more information officers have, the better they can deploy their resources in order to tackle ongoing issues.

“If you see something, say something,” Talley said.

After presenting the information, Cioffi thanked SAPD for their efforts, and explained she had been meeting with Vermont mayors to talk about traffic. A topic towns across the state are dealing with are e-bike riders, she said, and there’s been some discussion about how to educate people about their safe use. 

Before he left the council chambers, Talley gave a quick answer. If something has pedals, it’s legally considered a bike. Any vehicle with fixed pegs, however, requires registration, insurance and an inspection.

DFA smells and odors

After councilors wrapped up their traffic discussion, the last two hours of council featured the continuing back-and-forth around DFA’s sulfuric smell. Cloud presented the initial recap and argument together with city lawyer Ed Adrian.

The city’s early issues around DFA began in 2025 when the first smells started getting resident’s attention. People began to lodge complaints about the smell of rotten eggs which typically comes with sulphur soon after DFA installed new treatment equipment.

The city administration stepped up to work with DFA to tamp down on the problem, but after a summer of continuing problems, the deliberations had hit an impasse. Cloud brought the city administration’s first case to council by September of last year, asking alderpersons to impose a public health hazard order on DFA to try to put additional pressure on the plant to eliminate the odor.

Those first hearings led to a complaint collection period in October and additional deliberations between the city and DFA. Fall then led to the winter, when the smell was less expansive. 

The city administration and DFA, however, continued talks. Cloud said they ended up hiring Sanborn Head, an engineering firm, this past winter to try to get the necessary details to stop the problem. 

But by this summer, Cloud said the city continued to get complaints. Despite the months of collaborative efforts, another impasse had been reached between the two entities. If they declared DFA a public health hazard, however, there could be a legal solution in the courts, he said.

“I think you’ve wrestled with this long enough,” Adrian told council. “And it’s probably time for the courts to wrestle with it a bit more.”

Representing DFA, attorney Peter Raymond and DFA plant manager Panos Lekkas pushed back against the city’s arguments, as they contended the problem did not meet the legal definition of a public health hazard.

“The measurable level of odors that was largely non-detected at the property line was nowhere close to what has been deemed a public health hazard from standards like OSHA and other health authorities,” Raymond said.

But does it smell? Ward 1 Councilor Tim Hawkins pushed DFA’s representatives for an answer, and ultimately, most people did agree an odor existed. The problem remained, however, that the bounds of the smell and its intensity were still in question for all parties. The goals, too, seemed to differ.

After spending $47,000 on consultant groups, the city is pushing for a more substantial fix in an effort to eliminate the odor. 

“Let’s implement the recommendations of the experts that we brought in to advise us on how to solve the problem,” Cloud argued.

DFA, however, compared the plant to something like a pizza parlor. Yes, the place will smell like grease to the neighbors sometimes, but what can you expect if you live next to one? 

By the end of the discussion, City Council opted to moved forward with the declaration, voting unanimously for the ordinance, as they weren't sure if extending the timeline to track more complaints would help or continue to drag out the issue. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here