Gov. Phil Scott this week vetoed the Legislature’s most significant effort to lower health care costs, which was a surprise to legislators and many of those in the health care business, given Vermont’s struggles with health care costs that are among the nation’s highest.
The legislation was intended to expedite the state’s calendar for implementing reference-based pricing, a mechanism that would peg hospital pricing to a percentage of what Medicare pays for the same procedure. Vermont was the first state to begin a multi-year transition to reference-based pricing, with full implementation set for 2028. This year’s legislation - vetoed by Mr. Scott - would have allowed the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB]to begin the transition with plans sold through Vermont Health Connect and school employee health insurance. They are two of the state’s largest plans and two groups that would have the greatest statewide impact.
The governor vetoed the bill largely on matters of fairness. He said it was wrong to channel savings to the two groups without extending the savings to all Vermonters. “Vermont will not solve its affordability crisis by directing savings to some payers while excluding others.” He said the bill would add “unnecessary complexity, inequity, and cost.”
What’s odd about the governor’s complaints is that most Senate Republicans supported the measure, raising questions as to whether there are enough votes to override the governor’s veto. The bill was also supported by the GMCB, the state’s health care regulator, and the entity that oversees the march toward a more affordable health care system.
The flaw in the governor’s thinking is that the benefits are limited to school employees and those who seek coverage through Vermont Health Connect. That’s not a limitation, in any meaningful way. Health care costs for school employees are a sizable percentage of our schools’ budgets. If we reduce health care costs for schools, all property taxpayers benefit. Our Vermont Health Connect plans are the nation’s most expensive, and many Vermonters have dropped them due to the loss of federal support and the high cost of the plans. When people opt out of insurance, they often end up in the emergency room, which costs the health care system even more.
Given the support of the GMCB, many of the Legislature’s Republicans, school employees, Vermont Health Connect patrons, and the state’s property taxpayers, why wouldn’t the governor consider it an ideal bipartisan effort to a saner, more affordable health care system?
At this point, no plans have yet been announced to call the Legislature back for a veto session. But given the support for the bill, the number of Vermonters who would benefit, and the value of allowing the Green Mountain Care Board to have an additional year to test the reference-based system before its implementation in 2028, it would be worth the effort.
It’s also an election year and an important time for Vermonters to register their opinions on what most Vermonters consider to be a key consideration in how they live their lives in Vermont and at what cost.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here