St. Albans Messenger logo Essex Reporter logo Milton Independent logo Colchester Sun logo

Column: What book would you take to the grave?

Posted

George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor. Reach him at gatyle@gmail.com.

Summer reading season is here, and I can think of no sunnier way to embrace it than by asking what book you’d like to be buried with when you die.

Would you choose a quirky romance or detective story? Science fiction perhaps? Maybe that dense but important classic you’ve always meant to read? You’ll finally have time.

The question came to me after learning that archeologists recently uncovered the mummified remains of a 2,000-year-old Egyptian aristocrat buried with papyrus copies of the Iliad, the ancient Greek epic poem written about 800 years earlier by Homer.

Just to clear things up, the Odyssey was also written by Homer, but is more mythological than swashbuckling. Think Dune vs. Star Wars.

And just in time to demonstrate that those old sword and sandal sagas never go out of style, the 2026 blockbuster-hopeful version of the Odyssey, starring Matt Damon, will be coming to a theater or streaming service near you this summer, although it probably won’t be faithful to the original, so you might want to read it ahead of time. It’s only about a million pages.

As for our mummified patron of the Iliad, Dr. Leah Mascia, a specialist in the written and material culture of Greco-Roman and Late Antique Egypt at the Free University of Berlin muses that “… these sealed papyrus packets may have been regarded as part of an alternative funerary procedure.”

The idea was that snippets of Homer’s classic poem would protect the departed and ease his journey through the afterlife.

It seems that being Hellenistic-adjacent in the Egyptian Roman world conferred a special status which, apparently, extended to the great beyond. Having a copy of the Iliad mummified along with your mortal remains broadcasted your entitlement and helped you avoid the purgatorial messiness that the less fortunate Egyptian riff raff had to deal with when they kicked the bucket. It was like belonging to the lounge club at the airport, but for eternity and with really good snacks.

Mascia and her colleagues couldn’t tell if their literate mummy was actually planning to read the Iliad in the afterlife or if it was only intended as a status symbol, which adds some intriguing nuance to the question of what book we would choose to be buried with if we were inclined to be buried with a book.

Would it be something that makes a statement to some future archeologist who stumbles upon our grave? A book that proclaims who we were? What literary and spiritual currents moved us?

Or would we want a book we could read? Over and over again. Something that might tether us to humanity and remind us of who we once were?

I’m not sure I have a favorite book, but my spontaneous choice might be Irish writer John Banville’s Dr. Copernicus, the lively retelling of the life and times of Nicolas Copernicus, the 16th century astronomer who first showed that the earth orbits the sun.

Banville brings his motley crew of saintly and wicked characters to life with such graceful economy that it amazes me every time I read it. How does he do it? Where does this magic come from?

So, do you have a particular book in mind?

Hold that thought while I describe another news item that caught my eye. A Georgetown University neuroscientist, Adam Green, analyzed 370,000 college application essays to compare those written before and after ChatGPT was available to high school students.

Green’s team concluded that at first glance the post-AI essays were remarkably better. They were erudite and worldly. The grammar impeccable.

But beneath the sexy veneer, they were mostly just uninspired retellings of the same kind of homogenous ideas that high school students think college admissions officers want to hear.

The pre-AI essays were less skillfully written, but they were noticeably richer with originality and inspiration. The students had to put their own creative energies front and center, as blemished and imperfect as they might be.

As people who use it know, AI improves your prose the way a digital AutoTuner makes your voice sound like a rock god’s. AI can search instantaneously millions of texts for the statistically best way to structure your next sentence.

But come up with an original idea that wasn’t actually some programmer’s original idea? Nope.

Rebecca Winthrop, a Brookings Institute specialist on the impacts of AI, suggests that what’s in danger of being undervalued in the prioritizing of machine-enhanced perfection is the creative expression of the human experience that brings meaning into the world.

“Our species’ ability to come up with unexpected and original ideas is something to protect and nurture,” says Winthrop.

Exactly right. The books that inspire and entertain us while allowing us to still be our humble, imperfect, hopeful selves are the ones that live forever.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here